26 June 2020

'Come on, dogs, I'll take you on'

This post relates to a recent event in which a mentally unbalanced person threatened people with a knife - what is it with knives? - which led inevitably to an altercation with police.

He then thrust a knife through the driver's side window of one stopped car and repeatedly threatened to stab the motorist before telling him: "You better get out of here or I'll stab you."

This case has some interesting aspects. The first is the approach of the police, which makes me think either they had reason to not fear the suspect or they did not want to take the classic dickhead approach, which is commendable.

Ms Mulley said that two police officers approached, prompting Mr Scales-Copeland to yell at them, "come on, you dogs, I'll take you on" before lunging at them.

That escalated quickly.

The officers used capsicum spray and a baton to try to disarm him.

Absolutely commendable, whether this was protocol or their own initiative. I suspect this might have worked had they had sufficient baton training - that is to say I strongly suspect police do not receive nearly enough baton training. This is on the police bureaucracy and the NSW Government, but to be a little harsh, it is open to police officers to seek private training at their own expense, and I imagine such training would be tax-deductible. Nevertheless, it should not be up to some young person to take control of the situation when a wealthy modern state is simply being cheap.

Mr Scales-Copeland allegedly stabbed one senior constable five times in the left thigh. The other officer was stabbed a single time in the right hand, with one finger cut to the bone, Ms Mulley said.

I'm not sure how one gets stabbed 5 times in the thigh.

The officer with the severely injured hand ran into the traffic to escape. The retreating officer could feel the alleged attacker slashing at the back of his police vest.

Strong play. This by the way is what the state expects a civilian to do.

The prosecutor said this officer, who initially had problems unholstering his gun because of his hand injury, fired two shots at Scales-Copeland but missed.

It really worries me when police miss. Pistol shooting is difficult in the best of circumstances, greatly affected by one's psychological state, and is no doubt made much more difficult with a cut to the hand. Nevertheless police receive very little pistol training and practice. See again my comments above about baton training: again, this is a little harsh but I personally know people who, upon receiving a pistol but no training, took it upon themselves to learn to use their tool. I understand police work 4 days on, 4 days off: if they are not busy moonlighting as security guards they have the time to do so.

And then again:

The second officer yelled "drop the knife or we'll have to shoot", but Mr Scales-Copeland allegedly kept advancing so the policeman fired but also missed before his gun jammed.

Again, it worries me when police miss. I stress again that hitting is not easy, but where do those bullets go? Also, note he appears to not have cleared the jam. Clearing a jam when under mere time pressure in a pistol match is difficult enough let alone when someone has just stabbed you and is threatening to do it again. This is a training issue: it needs to be trained regularly. We taxpayers need to stop being so cheap.

Bystanders helped the injured officers eventually arrest Mr Scales-Copeland after he dropped the knife.

I wonder if they'll get prosecuted for their efforts like Trolley Man?

It is gratifying to see policing occurring as I envision it: the people are the police; the police are specialists there to lead and reinforce the people.

This young man is lucky to be alive. I am glad that he is: no parent should have to learn their child had a mental episode and was shot dead by police who just couldn't be bothered trying something else. These guys did try something else and paid a high price - and could have paid the ultimate price - for their efforts. They have my respect and my thanks.

Text source: Sydney Morning Herald


16 June 2020

Arming New Zealand Police


29 April 2019

Shang Dynasty

21 March 2019

Nationalists and kleptocrats

Without naming specific politicians in the Pacific region, [Foreign Minister Downer] added: “We have never tried to make ourselves popular with extremists, nationalists and kleptocrats.


22 January 2019

Father-daughter relationships strengthened with these three connectors

Key takeaway from this article:
Three things were raised repeatedly: the bond that working the land created, the significance of shared beliefs, and the connection between sport and a good father-daughter relationship. 
1. We don't really farm but maybe we could do gardening?
2. Shared beliefs: Really this seems to mean by all means challenge her beliefs but don't belittle them.
3. Sport: Actually could be any activity, but it should be a thing the father loves.

Doesn't need to be the father but could be any male role model.

20 May 2018

Four steps to fencing greatness

Top fencer recommends the following Four Steps:

  1. Pick some aspect of your fencing that you want to work on
  2. Think of a few related actions that can happen in a real bouting scenario
  3. Find a partner and create a drill giving him the option to use variations of those actions
  4. As you improve, add more options and increase the speed

25 August 2017

Superiority of Finnish police

I would need to look into it further to establish why the Finnish police are superior - or whether they are superior at all and this was, for example, this was merely a lucky shot, but...

The 2017 Turku stabbing is an example of superior police work. A young Moroccan man ran amok, stabbing about a dozen people, killing 2 and injuring 8. Three minutes later (!), police shot him in the thigh and arrested him. Police have since arrested 3 more people and issued an arrest warrant for another.

In NSW, they would have shot him dead. The reason is because, I believe, (a) a culture of cowardice; and (b) poor firearms standards.

NSW Police are essentially young people handed a weapon that they carry loaded with minimal training and supervision.

Such a person would not be and is not encouraged to aim at the thigh but at the centre of mass.

In the Finnish case, the suspect is still alive. This means he can assist police, perhaps unwillingly, perhaps unwittingly, with their investigations. It means he is not a martyr. It means he has years to reflect on what he has done and perhaps repent, which is not only humane, but serves the cause of the Enlightenment, including against obscurantist ideologies such as Islam.

While killing is sometimes inevitable, either because of the danger of the situation or because of the inherent difficulties that are necessarily a part of exercising violence, we win when we don't shoot to kill.